Wartburg Athletic Hall of Fame Selection Criteria:
- Must be Wartburg graduates, but need not have done all of their undergraduate work at Wartburg.
- Must have graduated at least 10 years prior to the award year.
- Must have been outstanding athletes at Wartburg as substantiated by All-Conference or All-American honors or career statistics.
- Must have demonstrated evidence of professional or personal achievement after graduation
- Must have made a contribution in the communities in which they have lived.